Concierge Doctor Sarasota

The term “Concierge Doctor Sarasota” gets used loosely, so here’s the concrete version: at Private Physician Services (PPS), a concierge physician carries a few hundred patients instead of the 2,000-plus common in a traditional practice. That single number is what makes everything else possible — the 45-minute new patient visit, the same-day call back, the doctor who remembers you had knee surgery three years ago without pulling up a chart first.

A lot of people arrive at this page after a frustrating experience elsewhere — a rushed visit, a long wait for an appointment, a doctor who clearly didn’t have time to actually listen — and want to know whether a concierge doctor is a real structural difference or just a marketing label. At PPS, founded in 2001 by Dr. Carlos Caballero after he left exactly that kind of high-volume, insurance-driven practice, it’s a real structural difference, built into how the practice has operated for over two decades.

How Concierge Medicine Works

A traditional Sarasota primary care visit is usually 10–15 minutes, scheduled weeks out, with a physician also managing a full waiting room. A concierge visit with a PPS physician typically runs 30–60 minutes, and new patients get a comprehensive intake covering family history, current medications, and health goals in a way a rushed visit simply can’t.

The other difference is what happens between visits. A traditional practice’s default is: call the office, leave a message, wait for a callback. A PPS member reaches their private physician directly and typically gets a same-day response for anything that can’t wait — which matters most exactly when it’s hardest to get, like during flu season or after an injury.

Book An Appointment

What to Expect During Your First Visit

A first visit with a PPS physician starts with a comprehensive review most patients have never had time for elsewhere: full family history, a real conversation about current medications and why they were prescribed, and a discussion of what you actually want out of your healthcare. This is the visit where the foundation for everything else gets built.

From there, the relationship works the way most people wish primary care always worked — direct access, proactive follow-up, and continuity if something more serious comes up. If a hospital stay is ever part of the picture, our page on in-hospital continuity covers a benefit most traditional practices don’t offer: a physician who stays involved even once you’re admitted, including coordination with teams at Sarasota Memorial Hospital.

Benefits Compared with Traditional Primary Care

Traditional Sarasota Primary Care vs. a PPS Concierge Doctor

Category	Traditional Primary Care	PPS Concierge Doctor
Visit length	10–15 minutes	30–60 minutes
New patient intake	Brief, symptom-focused	Comprehensive: history, medications, goals
Between-visit access	Message + callback, days later	Direct, typically same-day
Patient panel per physician	2,000+ common industry-wide*	A few hundred
Multiple concerns in one visit	Usually triaged to one issue	Room to address several at once

The Physician Behind This Model

PPS was founded in 2001 by Dr. Carlos F. Caballero, M.D., F.A.C.P., joined by Dr. Jose Santana and Dr. James Spain, all board certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine — each applying the same deliberately small-panel model. Full physician credentials are on our board certified & Ivy League physician page.

Read More

The Local Detail That Matters Here

Sarasota has grown fast enough that many longtime residents have watched their own doctor’s practice get bigger and less personal over the years — not because the doctor changed, but because insurance-billed medicine rewards volume. Concierge medicine is a structural fix to that, not just a marketing label. That growth pattern shows up differently depending on where in the area you live — a downtown Sarasota (34236) condo resident’s scheduling problem looks different from a Lakewood Ranch (34211) family’s new-patient waitlist problem.

PPS is based in Sarasota and serves the city’s neighborhoods — including Downtown Sarasota, Southside Village, West of the Trail, and the areas surrounding Payne Park — alongside our broader Gulf Coast coverage area of Siesta Key, Longboat Key, Lakewood Ranch, Palmer Ranch, Lido Key, and Venice.

By the Numbers

Nationally, traditional primary care panels commonly run into the thousands per physician, and average visit length is often reported around 15–20 minutes based on CDC National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey (NAMCS) data. A PPS concierge panel of a few hundred patients per physician is what allows a 30–60 minute visit to be the norm rather than the exception.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many patients does a typical doctor have compared to a concierge doctor?

A traditional primary care physician’s panel is commonly reported in the thousands. Concierge physicians, including ours, intentionally keep that number much smaller — which is what makes same-day access and longer visits possible.

Does a concierge doctor do anything medically different from a regular doctor?

No — the medicine itself is the same. What’s different is the amount of time and attention available per patient, since the panel size is so much smaller.

Can I still see my current specialists if I switch to a concierge doctor?

Yes. Your PPS physician coordinates with any specialists you already see; switching to concierge primary care doesn’t require changing anyone else on your care team.

Is a concierge doctor the same as a 'private doctor'?

The terms are used interchangeably in most cases. Both describe this same membership-based, smaller-panel model.

What if I only have one minor concern — do I still get a long appointment?

Appointment length is based on what’s needed, not a fixed slot; a minor concern doesn’t require using the full visit, but the time is available if something more comes up.

Are PPS physicians board certified?

Yes — every physician at PPS, including Dr. Caballero and Dr. Santana, is board certified by the American Board of Internal Medicine, with ongoing recertification through continuing education.